Peer Feedback Sheet: ASS#2 Step 10

Feedback From: Makayla Comelli

Feedback To: Amy McClelland

	My Comments
Step 7   Identify three products or services of your firm   Estimate selling price, variable cost & CM   Commentary – Contribution margins   Constraints – Identify & Commentary	Your three products were spread out really well and detailed. To my knowledge your calculations add up as well, so it looks like you’re on the right track
Step 8   Calculation of ratios   Ratios – commentary (blog)   Calculate economic profit   Commentary – drivers of economic profit	Everything was linked properly in your ratios and your blog posts were very visually appealing. I like how you put your own personality and character into your blog. It really sets your blog aside from the rest.
Step 9   Develop capital investment decision for your firm   Calculation of payback period, NPV & IRR   Recommendation & discussion	I agree with the decision you made, and you had a very well planned and detailed capital investment decision and your calculations appear to be correct
Overall ASS#2 Steps 7-9	Overall, I can see you have been really active on your blog and you have done a good job at presenting your assignment with detailed and educated responses

Peer Feedback Sheet: ASS#2 Step 10

Feedback From: Makayla Comelli

Feedback To: Yxin Cao

	My Comments
Step 7   Identify three products or services of your firm   Estimate selling price, variable cost & CM   Commentary – Contribution margins   Constraints – Identify & Commentary	From my understanding, your contribution margin was calculated correctly. you had a detailed discussion and made some really good points regarding your products and decision.
Step 8   Calculation of ratios   Ratios – commentary (blog)   Calculate economic profit   Commentary – drivers of economic profit	Your spreadsheet was very well done and everything was linked properly. Your blog posts were informative and also very visually appealing which was good to see because it made it more entertaining to review.   I can also see you kept active with your blog in this unit and provided a lot of useful information for everyone.   Your blog was definitely one of my favourites and I actually looked at it a few times to help me with my own work.
Step 9   Develop capital investment decision for your firm   Calculation of payback period, NPV & IRR   Recommendation & discussion	This step was very informative and I agree with the decision you made as well. I found step 9 to be a hard step for me but you made it look so easy. You detailed and explained your reasoning behind your choice very well.
Overall ASS#2 Steps 7-9	Overall, this was one of the best assignments I have seen and I can tell you have been very active in this unit in your blog and you have also been engaging in the content very well as it has shown throughout your entire assignments.

Peer Feedback Sheet: ASS#2 Step 10

Feedback From: Makayla Comelli

Feedback To: Caitlin Yarrow

	My Comments
Step 7   Identify three products or services of your firm   Estimate selling price, variable cost & CM   Commentary – Contribution margins   Constraints – Identify & Commentary	This step was a really interesting read as the product that you chose really seemed to work and your contribution margin looks great.
Step 8   Calculation of ratios   Ratios – commentary (blog)   Calculate economic profit   Commentary – drivers of economic profit	From my understanding your ratios seemed to work   You commentary on your blog post about ratios was nice and clear
Step 9   Develop capital investment decision for your firm   Calculation of payback period, NPV & IRR   Recommendation & discussion	Your capital investment decision was really thought out and detailed nicely. You presented your calculations neatly and I agree with the option you chose.
Overall ASS#2 Steps 7-9	Overall I can see you have put in a lot of hard work and your assignment looks very well done.